|
My disdain for most progressive or power metal is usually not found within the music itself. I, in fact, love the ability
of these artists to take different influences, ranging from classical to heavy metal, and blend them in a way that is not
only pleasing to the ear, but in a way that is musical. It does not become cluttered noise from random pieces. It becomes
a coherent musical endeavor.
My disdain, however is usually directed at one specific member of the band. And that member's job is probably the most
important. He or She occupies the forefront over the music. That person, of course, is the vocalist.
It's not that the vocalist of Eyefear is horrible. It is not that the vocals on the disc make it impossible for me to
listen to this disc. But, it is the case that I find the vocals distracting for what is going on behind them. Yes, I know
that it is customary to have a vocalist that resembles, in voice, the castrated youths of the classical period. But, I find
myself enjoying the vocal stylings of Matthew Barlow, ex-Iced Earth, or Warrell Dane, the present day singer of Nevermore.
Another problem with this approach to vocals is that there are no memorable moments found inside of it. I can recall the
melodies, rhythms, and solos from the guitars, but when I listen to multiple songs, the vocals just blend together.
For me to sit here in my seat of authority and bring my wrath against the full band for one member's misdeeds seems to
be harsh. But, the band (and the readers of this review) should know better. I am the Metal Judge. I do not have to be just
in my judgment. My decision is that they should cut back on the ear-peircing vocals, and mix it up with some vocals in a lower
(maybe much lower) octave. For variety is a very good thing, and offers more possibilities. A progressive band should know
this, as they mix things up in the instruments, and is not the voice just another instrument?
|
